Double Toasted

^[3]

Steve-O

^[4]

C. Robert Cargill

Andre Meadows

[5]

^[6]

Jackie Venson

Mark Ellis of Schmoes Know

[7]

Tommy McGrew – The first regular co-host to be added to the show after the closing of Spill.com. McGrew has not appeared on the site since 2016 when he was involved in a fatal hit and run accident, killing a pedestrian. Despite being a "hit and run," Tommy did eventually return to the scene later to realized he had hit a person and not an animal (as he originally thought). Besides the initial update to Tommy's situation in mid 2016, Korey Coleman, and the rest of the Double Toasted crew have refrained from mentioning his name on the site, similar to the with Chris Benoit. Korey has stated only once, after getting many emails about Tommy's return to the site, that the chances of McGrew returning to the site is highly unlikely.^[30] However, Tommy made a surprise appearance on a February 2019 show where he revealed that he did not get any jail time, but is on probation for ten years and had to seek therapy to help cope with the fact that he killed someone. He says that after 10 years of good behavior, he will be given a clean slate. He has expressed interest in returning,^[31] but Korey confirmed that it would be impossible for things to go back to the way it was.^[32]

WWE

Christopher "Juicy" Herman - Former co-host on The Sunday Service and 8-Bit Crumbs. He's known for his amicable personality on and off camera. He tends to have very staunch opinions on film and television that sometimes clash with the rest of the crew. A running gag involves his lack of knowledge regarding music. He runs a side account on where he will read fanfiction relating to Sonic the Hedgehog while dressed as the titular character. In August 2023, he left the website to focus on his own online content. Korey later revealed that he fired Herman due to his temper.

OnlyFans

Merve "Mia" Coleman - Former co-host on What Up Son and occasional co-host on various shows. She is from Turkey and she is also the ex-wife of Korey Coleman. While not as seasoned due to her upbringing, she can make a conversation interesting and occasionally brings very intuitive insight. Upon divorcing Korey, she left the site.

Patrick Girts – Former co-host on the High Score, The Movie Review Extravaganza and The Weekly Roast and Toast. Girts chose to leave due to the stresses of working on three shows late at night and wanting to focus on a career in marketing. He still makes occasional appearances and is the usually the subject of Korey's numerous diatribes.

Danielle Dallaire – Former co-host on What Up Son and occasionally co-hosted on various shows. She left to pursue other opportunities. Though Danielle had initially claimed that it would only be for a year, Korey Coleman has openly doubted it with Danielle confirming that it was a long term job. Her final show was on May 14, 2018. In mid-2021, Danielle returned, seemingly as a regular and began to appear more often. On November 9, 2021, Korey announced that he banned her from the show due to her behavior. However, on May 21, 2023, Danielle made an unexpected guest appearance.

[33]

Korey Goodwin – Former host of The High Score and co-host on The Weekly Roast and Toast and The Movie Review Extravaganza. He can speak Mandarin. His final show was on June 13, 2018. He left to go focus on his own personal career. He still makes occasional appearances.

[34]

Sam "Sammy" González – Former editor and regulator of the fan pages. Host on Sammy Ain't Seen Sh*t. Occasional co-host on various shows. He left to pursue other interests. His final show was on April 28, 2019. He still makes occasional appearances.

[32]

Ian Butcher – Former co-host on Sammy Ain't Seen Sh*t and Toast to Toast.

Taylor "Kung-Fu T.J." Manatsa – Former co-host on The High Score. He still makes occasional appearances.

Chase Arthur – Former co-host of the Double Dribble.

Ray Villareal – Also known as rapper "Tone Royal", former co-host of the Double Dribble. He still makes occasional appearances.

William Valle – Former editor and contributor for the site. Occasional co-host on various shows. He talked about controversial topics. He still makes occasional appearances.

Shea Young – The first female cast member added to the site. Shea left in February 2016 to pursue other opportunities, and because of negative fan reaction to her. She is the only former member who have not made an appearance after leaving the site. Her current location is unknown.

[35]

Robert "DJ Milez" Araya – Former co-host on What's in the Box.

Christian Torres - Former Co-host on The Daily Double Talk, former co-host on What's in the Box. Author of comic, Here We Are Lost.

Carlos Nieves - Former fill in co-host on What Up Son and occasional guest on various shows. He is from Puerto Rico and worked on the site helping run the servers to keep it up. He is known for his thick accent and propensity to ramble about subjects, most of which he ends up getting wrong or confusing for something else. Korey has a tendency to pick on him for many of his passionate outbursts.

on YouTube

Double Toasted's channel

at IMDb

Double Toasted