Katana VentraIP

2010 United States Senate special election in Massachusetts

The 2010 United States Senate special election in Massachusetts was a special election held on January 19, 2010, in order to fill the Massachusetts Class I United States Senate seat for the remainder of the term ending January 3, 2013. It was won by Republican candidate Scott Brown.

For related races, see 2010 United States Senate elections.

The vacancy that prompted the special election was created by the death of Democratic Senator Ted Kennedy on August 25, 2009. Kennedy had served as a U.S. senator since 1962, having been elected in a special election to fill the vacancy created when his brother John F. Kennedy was elected president of the United States in 1960. The seat was held until the election by an appointee, Senator Paul Kirk, a former chairman of the Democratic National Committee, who was not a candidate in the election to complete the term. This was the first open seat U.S. senate election in Massachusetts since 1984 and the first in this seat since 1962 where Ted Kennedy was first elected.


A party primary election determining the winners of party nominations was held on December 8, 2009.[1][2] The Democratic Party nominated Martha Coakley, the Massachusetts attorney general; the Republican Party nominated Scott Brown, a Massachusetts state senator. The race drew national attention due to Brown's unexpectedly closing the gap and running even with, or ahead of, Coakley in independent and internal polling in the last few days of the campaign.[3][4]


Polls closed at 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time. At 9:06 p.m., BNO News projected Brown as the winner of the race.[5] At 9:13 p.m., The Boston Globe reported that Coakley telephoned Brown and conceded her defeat in the election.[6] As a result of the election, the Republicans would control 41 seats in the United States Senate, enough to successfully make the Senate filibuster happen.[7] Although Democrats would retain control of both houses of Congress until January 2011, Brown's victory would greatly affect their political plans, most notably for the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, though the legislation was signed into law two months later.[8][9]


With his victory, Brown became the first Republican to win this seat since 1946, and the first to win either Massachusetts Senate seat since 1972. Indeed, he was the first Massachusetts Republican to be elected to Congress since Peter Blute and Peter Torkildsen won reelection to the House in 1994. As of 2023, this is the last congressional election in Massachusetts won by a Republican. The only Massachusetts congressional Republican throughout his whole Senate tenure, Brown lost his bid for a full term in 2012; he later moved to New Hampshire where he unsuccessfully ran for U.S. Senate in 2014. This election was the first time since 1946 that the winner of Massachusetts's Class 1 Senate seat was not a member of the Kennedy family.

Background[edit]

Timeline[edit]

Massachusetts law requires a special election to be held on a Tuesday, no fewer than 145 days, nor more than 160 days from the date of office vacancy, on a date determined by the governor. That range placed the election date between January 17 and February 1, 2010.[1][10][11] Massachusetts law specifies that a party primary shall be held the sixth Tuesday before the general election.[12] On August 28, 2009, Secretary of the Commonwealth William F. Galvin presented the dates January 19 and 26, 2010, after meetings with State House Speaker Robert DeLeo, State Senate President Therese Murray, and aides to Governor Deval Patrick. Patrick was legally required to select one of these two dates. A January 19 election would require the primary to be held on December 8, while a January 26 election would have required a December 15 primary.[1] Republican State Representative Karyn Polito suggested on August 28, 2009, that, because the possible election dates overlap the holiday season, the law ought to be rewritten to allow the special election to be held on November 3, 2009, to coincide with other elections in the state.[13]


Patrick stated on August 29, 2009, that he wanted to honor a request by Kennedy that any appointee to the seat not run, and that he would address the issue of the election date "after we have finished this period of respectful grief."[13] On August 31, 2009, Patrick scheduled the special election for January 19, 2010, with the primary elections on December 8, 2009. For party primary candidates, completed nomination papers with certified signatures were required to be filed by the close of business, November 3, 2009. Non-party candidates had a December 8, 2009, filing deadline.[2][14][15]

Qualifications[edit]

A senator must, by the date of inauguration, be at least thirty years old, a U.S. citizen for at least nine years, and a state inhabitant of the state wishing to represent.[16] In Massachusetts, candidates for the U.S. Senate must file nomination papers with certified signatures of 10,000 Massachusetts voters, by deadlines established by the Secretary of the Commonwealth.[17] A candidate for nomination in a party's special primary election must have been an enrolled member of the party, through filing as a member of that party with the Secretary of the Commonwealth using a certificate of voter registration, for the 90 days preceding the filing deadline, unless the candidate is a newly registered voter. The candidate additionally must not have been enrolled in any other party in the prior year.[18]

Member of the U.S. House of Representatives for the 8th district, announced his candidacy on September 18, 2009.[40]

Mike Capuano

Massachusetts Attorney General, announced her candidacy on September 3, 2009.[41]

Martha Coakley

co-founder and former CEO of City Year, announced his candidacy on September 24, 2009.[42]

Alan Khazei

a managing director of private equity firm Bain Capital and managing partner of the Boston Celtics basketball team, announced his candidacy on September 17, 2009.[43][44]

Stephen Pagliuca

State Senator

Scott Brown

Jack E. Robinson III, former nominee for , Secretary of the Commonwealth (2002), and U.S. House of Representatives (2006)[46]

U.S. Senate (2000)

Joseph L. Kennedy, a member of the , ran as an independent.[56] He has no relation to the politically prominent Kennedy family.[57]

Libertarian Party

Independent or third party candidates had until December 8, 2009, to submit nomination papers for signature certification.[14]

(largest municipality: Barnstable)

Barnstable

(largest municipality: New Bedford)

Bristol

(largest municipality: Lynn)

Essex

(largest municipality: Springfield)

Hampden

(largest municipality: Quincy)

Norfolk

(largest municipality: Brockton)

Plymouth

(largest municipality: Worcester)

Worcester

President , via political advisor David Axelrod – "I think that there were a lot of elements to the message [in the election]. Health care was part of it."[152]

Barack Obama

(D-NY) – "I think you can make a pretty good argument that health care might be dead."[153]

Anthony Weiner

(D-VA) – "The race was a referendum not only on health care reform but also on the openness and integrity of our government process. It is vital that we restore the respect of the American people in our system of government and in our leaders. To that end, I believe it would only be fair and prudent that we suspend further votes on health care legislation until Senator-elect Brown is seated."

Jim Webb

(D-CA) – "Whatever happens in Massachusetts, we will pass quality, affordable health care for all Americans and it will be soon."[154]

Nancy Pelosi

(D-NV) – "We're not going to rush into anything, we're going to wait until the new senator arrives before we do anything more on health care."[155]

Harry Reid

(D-MD) – "We will all be making a mistake if we believe that the message that was delivered in Massachusetts last night was unique to Massachusetts. That anger was directed, frankly, at all of us."[156]

Steny Hoyer

(D-MA) – "I think the measure that would have passed, that is, some compromise between the House and Senate bill, which I would have voted for, although there were some aspects of both bills I would have liked to see change, I think that's dead. It is certainly the case that the bill that would have passed, a compromise between the House and Senate bills, isn't going to pass, in my judgment, and certainly shouldn't. We are back to where we were maybe even years ago. That is, there is now no bill that I believe can pass or should pass. Sen. Snowe may be willing to work now with her Democratic colleagues, and maybe 3, 4, 5, 6 other Republicans would be, to try and put something together. If that's not the case, and Sen. Snowe and others aren't for some fairly significant changes, then we'll go into the election with the health care status quo."[157]

Barney Frank

(D-MI) – "At this point, we'll be looking to see what the mood of the House is and what they want to do. There's no willingness to abandon ship on healthcare. I would be very satisfied if the House passed what the Senate did and then we can work on those areas that need to be strengthened or fixed. Those of us who worked very hard on the Senate bill believe that this is a good bill. It's not perfect; neither is the House bill. But the reality is, this would be a major step forward for lowering costs for families [and] small businesses [and] strengthening Medicare."[158]

Debbie Stabenow

(D-WI) – "It's probably back to the drawing board on health care, which is unfortunate, because everybody agrees we have to do something about health care and so it would be unfortunate to lose this whole effort."[159]

Russ Feingold

List of United States senators from Massachusetts

2017 United States Senate special election in Alabama

2021 Virginia gubernatorial election

of Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth]

Elections Division

from OurCampaigns.com

Massachusetts U.S. Senate

from Open Secrets

Campaign contributions

graph of multiple polls from Pollster.com

2010 Massachusetts Senate Special

from CQ Politics

2010 Massachusetts Senate Race

The 2010 Massachusetts Senate Race

Massachusetts Senate Democratic Candidate Debate

Scott Brown for Senate